After the Bell: Miss Oseguera Reviews Pepp’s May Pizza Lineup

May 4, 2026

Pepperonis, we MAY have created some new fan-favorites this month at Pepp’s Pizzeria in Urbandale.

Jasmine Oseguera, better known as Miss O, is this month’s After the Bell guest teacher. She’s a fifth-grade teacher at Waukee Elementary, and she came ready to grade these pizzas like a pro.

Here’s how the May lineup stacked up:

Barbecue (BBQ) chicken pizza at Pepp's Pizzeria

Cinco de Mayo (May 4-9)

A festive pie bringing bold flavors together with a cilantro lime drizzle, fire roasted corn, and a crunchy finish from tortilla strips—all on our signature 24-hour cold fermented crust.

“I really like the sauce… it’s a really good sauce. And I like the crunch from the tortilla strips. Flavors are working really well together.”

Miss O is a “saucy girl,” but even wanting a little extra didn’t stop her from enjoying this one.

Grade:
Grade B
Meatball pizza at Pepp's pizzeria

Buffalo Bang (May 11-16)

Think buffalo chicken wrap, but on a pizza. Breaded chicken, balanced buffalo ranch sauce, and just the right amount of kick.

“That is really good. The buffalo sauce is not super spicy, which I love. This is very good for me… definitely my vibe.”

This one came in hot (but not too hot) and delivered big on flavor.

Grade:
Grade B+
Elote pizza at Pepp's pizzeria

Hawaiian Sweet Fire (May 18-23)

Sweet meets heat with pineapple, jalapeño, and a mango habanero aioli drizzle.

“The pineapple balances the spice, which is very good. I love pineapple on pizza… but if you don’t love spice, this might not be your favorite.”

A great option for those who like a little bit of both in every bite.

Grade:
Grade A
Thanksgiving pizza at Pepp's Pizzeria

Potluck Pickle Roll (May 25-30)

Midwest sushi who?? We all know someone who makes a great pickle roll… and now you know someone who makes a great pickle roll PIZZA!

“Tastes just like a pickle roll-up. The pickle has a really good crunch, and the cream cheese makes it super delicious.”

This one is a nostalgic favorite that hits close to home.

Grade:
Grade A+

Grade:
Grade A+

🌟 The Gold Star Winner... Buffalo Bang!

This was a tough one, but Miss O gave her top spot to the Buffalo Bang! “I think my gold star might go to the Buffalo Bang… it was really banging.”

🍕 Try the May Pizza Specials at Pepp's Pizzeria in Urbandale, Iowa

All limited-time pizza specials are available this month at Pepp’s Pizzeria — served as whole pies, personal pies, or by the slice. Visit us at 4640 86th Street in Urbandale, Iowa, or explore our full menu to see why we’re a go-to for some of the best pizza in Des Moines. Order online and use code 10OSEGUERO to get 10% off your order throughout May.

Nominate a Teacher You Love!

Thank you so much to Miss Oseguera for reviewing our May specials! At Pepp's, we're proud to support local educators across the Des Moines area who show up for their students every single day. Each month, we treat one deserving teacher to a FREE pizza party.

Help us choose the next winner — submit your nomination today!

Pepp’s Pizzeria – Urbandale’s Home for Crust You Dream About (and Pizza You Brag About)

📍 4640 86th Street, Urbandale, IA (Open Monday-Saturday from 11 am-8:30 pm)

❤️ Serving up local flavor, creative monthly specials, and a side of Iowa Nice.

Recent Posts

Browse All

After the Bell: Coach Delaney Reviews Pepp's April Pizza Lineup

April specials at Pepp’s Pizzeria in Urbandale, IA: Crab Rangoon, Green Jacket, Chicken Creole, All American, Pit Boss

After the Bell: Mr. Battista Reviews Pepp's March Pizza Lineup

March pizza specials at Pepp's Pizzeria in Urbandale, IA: Potsticker, Philly, Reuben, and Cuban. Stop in for a slice!